Description
Reverend Paul Cuffee, a Shinnecock Indian, is buried at a site marked by a single fenced grave. This location was chosen for his burial because it was once the meeting place of the old Indian church. It is also located in "Good Ground," the original name for Hampton Bays. Cuffee was a well-known minister, following in the footsteps of his grandfather, Peter John, who had also preached to Native American communities on Long Island. In his youth, Cuffee was an indentured servant to a farmer in Wading River but later became a dedicated convert to Christianity in his early 20s. He went on to preach in several Indian communities, including the Poospatuck Reservation (present-day Mastic Beach), Canoe Place in Hampton Bays, and Montauk. His passionate sermons drew large crowds. Cuffee passed away on March 7, 1812, at the age of 55, and his grave marker reads: "In testifying the Gospel of the Grace of God He finished his course with Joy." This simple, broken marker remains as a testament to his life and work among the Indigenous people of Long Island.








